While the funding didn’t arrive, the promise is still alive

29 09 2010

Earlier this year, the U.S. Department of Education invited communities to apply for a grant from the Promise Neighborhoods Program.  Building off work done by Geoffrey Canada at the Harlem Children’s Zone, the Promise Neighborhoods Program was designed to provide funding to improve the educational and developmental outcomes of children in the nation’s most distressed communities. The funding could support efforts that:

  • help leaders and members of the community understand the state of children in their neighborhoods;
  • connect schools, families and the community to support children from the cradle through college to career;
  • help agencies and programs work effectively together;
  • help the public and private sectors work together to spread best practices beyond the pilot neighborhood; and
  • institute a rigorous evaluation of the program.

Grant winners receive a one-year planning grant. In subsequent years, contingent on the availability of funds, the Department intends to conduct competitions for implementation grants, as well as competitions for new planning grants.

Seven of the 339 applications received by the Promise Neighborhoods Program came from Michigan. Data Driven Detroit served as a data resource three of our state’s applicants. Detroit’s Black Family Development applied to help transform the Osborn and Chadsey-Condon neighborhoods. Data Driven Detroit served as a data resource while City Connect Detroit assisted in the project coordination and proposal writing.

Data Driven Detroit also met with the team from Focus Hope which submitted a proposal for their neighborhood, and provided data support to an effort on the city’s east side.

On September 21, Secretary of Education Arne Duncan announced the 21 recipients who will share $10 million.  While no Detroit applicant was chosen to become a Promise Neighborhood, the Guidance Center in Southgate received $500,000 to work with the River Rouge School District.  We congratulate the Guidance Center and look forward to learning more about their effort over the next year.

Of course, Detroit feels a deep sense of disappointment at being passed over for a Promise Neighborhoods grant. But while working on the proposals, I was impressed by the dedication and sense of possibility that the communities generated as they imagined a new environment that’s supportive of children. During the proposal writing process, the message was clear among all of the Detroit applicants: the “promise” would move forward, with or without the grant.  

The Promise Neighborhoods Program has served as a key driver for discussions across the country.  The release of the documentary, “Waiting for Superman,” coupled with the “Education Nation”   series on NBC News this week, and the education conference in Washington, D.C., have served to raise the level of discussion around education at all levels. We must make sure that this week’s “buzz” does not fizzle but, rather, leads to a clarion call in Detroit, the region, the state and the nation, that educational reform must occur at all levels.

 





RIGHT START: MATERNAL AND INFANT WELL-BEING IN DETROIT

1 03 2010

When it comes to a healthy start for all children in Detroit, I don’t want to talk about teens or unwed mothers. I want to talk about babies starting out life with a real disadvantage–and what we’re going to do about it.  

This month, Data Driven Detroit released a ground-breaking study –”Right Start in Detroit 2009: Maternal and Infant Well-Being in the City of Detroit, 2000-2007.” We worked with the Detroit Department of Health and Wellness Promotion to look at birth statistics by neighborhood–something that has never been done before in the city. What we found is that maternal and infant well-being varies vastly from neighborhood to neighborhood.

In Palmer Woods, only 10 percent of births are to teen mothers. In the Winterhalter subcommunity, nearly one in three babies is born to a teenager. The Vernor and Chadsey-Condon subcommunities have the highest shares of mothers without high school diplomas. And despite an overall decrease in the Detroit birth rate between 2000 and 2007, the Chadsey-Condon and Jeffries subcommunities have both registered an increase in the same period.

Our study really shows that place matters. Where you live can affect how you start out in life, and it can profoundly affect your ability to thrive for years to come. 

Getting public policy off to a Right Start 

The policy implications are clear. We would be smart to target our thinly-stretched resources directly at the problem we are trying to address.If five communities have 24 percent or more births to teens–Osborn (24 percent), St. Jean (25 percent), Conner (25 percent), Burbank (26 percent) and Winterhalter (27 percent)-then perhaps those communities should be getting the lion’s share of our prevention, education and maternal health care services. That’s why good, accurate research is key to developing effective public policy that makes real change to the lives of those who live in Detroit. 

Which brings me to my second point. One study is not enough to answer critical questions about mother-child outcomes in Detroit. We know that in the Conner subcommunity, nearly half of the infants received inadequate prenatal care. What the study does not reveal is why. Is there a lack of health care institutions in the area? Do the mothers lack health insurance? Is there a cultural mistrust of doctors? Are there language or educational barriers? Are cigarettes and liquor more available in the community than fresh fruits and vegetables? 

Data Driven Detroit’s report has been well-received in the media. It’s my hope that it’s not only a “Right Start” for the mothers and children in Detroit, but it marks a right start for the use of data to inform public policy as well.  To find out the results for your neighborhood, click on the links below:

Airport  
Bagley  
Belle Isle  
Boynton
Brightmoor  
Brooks  
Burbank  
Central  
Cerveny  
Chadsey-Condon  
Chene  
Cody-Rouge  
Conner  
Denby  
Downtown  
Durfee  
Evergreen  
Finney  
Grandmont  
Greenfield  
Harmony Village  
Jeffries  
Kettering-Butzel  
Mack  
Mackenzie  
McNichols  
Osborn  
Palmer Park  
Pembroke  
Pershing  
Redford  
Rosa Parks  
Rosedale Park  
St Jean  
State Fair-Nolan  
Tireman  
University  
Vernor  
Winterhalter  







Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 54 other followers

%d bloggers like this: